Ventilation–Perfusion Matching and Mismatch

Gas exchange requires fresh gas and blood to reach the same lung regions. Adequate total ventilation and cardiac output do not guarantee that local delivery is well matched. The distribution determines the gas composition within each region, and the mixture leaving all regions determines the arterial result.

31.1 The Ratio Compares Two Flows in the Same Region

Alveolar ventilation here is the flow of fresh gas reaching alveolar regions. Pulmonary perfusion is the flow of blood through their capillaries. The ventilation–perfusion ratio compares these flows within a lung unit or a defined collection of units.

The dots indicate flow per unit time. Both quantities are commonly expressed in L/min, with the gas-volume convention specified for ventilation. Their ratio is conventionally treated as dimensionless. It does not represent the fraction of oxygen removed from gas, the percentage of cardiac output entering a region, or the fraction of a breath that reaches alveoli.

Consider illustrative whole-lung alveolar ventilation of 4 L/min and pulmonary blood flow of 5 L/min. The first number describes fresh alveolar gas delivered each minute. The second describes blood delivered each minute. Their ratio is 4/5 = 0.8. This is a useful resting teaching example, not a target that every region must reach.

Use regional alveolar ventilation rather than total minute ventilation in this calculation. Minute ventilation includes gas moving through conducting airways. Fresh gas reaching poorly perfused or unperfused alveoli still belongs on the ventilation side of the distribution. The effective alveolar ventilation inferred from carbon dioxide elimination is a related but different whole-lung quantity. State which meaning is being used.

The ratio also does not establish the absolute magnitude of exchange. A region receiving 1 L/min of ventilation and 1 L/min of blood has a ratio of 1. Another receiving 0.1 L/min of each has the same ratio but handles one tenth of those flows. A ratio describes their relationship, while the component flows determine how much gas and blood the region processes.

A local ratio affects gas composition only within a broader set of conditions. Inspired oxygen, incoming venous blood, metabolism, and exchange across the barrier remain relevant. The same ratio need not produce identical gas tensions when those inputs change.

31.2 A Normal Overall Ratio Can Conceal a Broad Distribution

The lung consists of many exchanging regions in parallel. Each receives a share of ventilation and a share of blood flow. The overall ratio divides total alveolar ventilation by total pulmonary blood flow. It does not show how evenly those flows are paired.

Divide the illustrative lung into two equally perfused compartments, each receiving 2.5 L/min of blood. If each also receives 2 L/min of alveolar ventilation, both ratios are 2/2.5 = 0.8. Ventilation and perfusion are distributed proportionally.

Now direct only 0.5 L/min of ventilation to the first compartment and 3.5 L/min to the second. Their ratios become 0.5/2.5 = 0.2 and 3.5/2.5 = 1.4. Total ventilation remains 4 L/min, total blood flow remains 5 L/min, and the whole-lung ratio remains 0.8. The local exchange conditions have nevertheless changed substantially.

The poorly ventilated compartment receives more blood than its fresh gas delivery can adequately oxygenate. The well-ventilated compartment cannot necessarily compensate. Its hemoglobin may already be nearly saturated, leaving limited capacity to add enough oxygen content to offset the deficit from the first region.

Distributions can be described from two perspectives. A perfusion distribution shows how much blood passes through each range of ratios. A ventilation distribution shows how much ventilation enters those ranges. The first helps explain the blood mixture leaving the lung; the second helps explain where ventilation is being used.

Wagner and colleagues applied a multiple inert gas method in normal subjects and measured distributions rather than one average ratio. Their work demonstrated measurable inequality even in healthy lungs and examined changes with inspired oxygen and posture. A physiologically useful description therefore allows heterogeneity without equating every regional difference with disease. 1

31.3 Gravity and Posture Change Both Ventilation and Perfusion

In an upright healthy lung, both ventilation and perfusion generally increase toward dependent regions, but perfusion often changes more steeply. The ratio consequently tends to be higher toward the apex and lower toward the base. The base can receive more ventilation in absolute terms while still having less ventilation relative to its blood flow.

Ventilation depends partly on regional inflation at the start of inspiration. Less dependent regions are often already more expanded. Dependent regions may undergo a larger tidal volume change when they remain open. Airway closure, edema, altered chest-wall mechanics, and mechanical ventilation can change this pattern.

West and Dollery used radioactive carbon dioxide to study regional perfusion and ventilation–perfusion differences in humans. Their measurements established important positional gradients and showed changes with exercise and recumbency. These experiments describe physiological patterns under their measurement conditions, rather than fixed ratios for every anatomical level. 2

Vascular pressures help explain perfusion. Hydrostatic pressure changes with height, while alveolar and surrounding pressures influence whether vessels remain open. West, Dollery, and Naimark manipulated vascular and alveolar pressures in an isolated perfused lung. Their experiments demonstrated how these pressure relationships determine regional flow. 3

The resulting pressure zones describe flow conditions. They are not permanent anatomical bands or direct labels for low and high V̇_A/Q̇. Blood volume, vascular pressure, alveolar pressure, lung volume, and body position can move their boundaries.

Petersson and colleagues used quantitative imaging in healthy volunteers to compare upright and horizontal postures. Gravity redistributed both ventilation and blood flow, with a larger upright effect on perfusion. Their findings also show why a simple apex-to-base explanation cannot capture all heterogeneity in supine or prone lungs. 4

31.4 Low and High Ratios Change Alveolar Gas in Opposite Directions

A low ratio means that fresh alveolar gas delivery is small relative to blood flow. Blood continues to remove oxygen and deliver carbon dioxide, but ventilation replaces oxygen and clears carbon dioxide relatively slowly. Alveolar oxygen tension falls and carbon dioxide tension rises toward the values in incoming venous blood as the ratio becomes very small.

Blood leaving that region therefore has lower oxygen content than blood leaving a well-matched region, assuming adequate equilibration. Airway narrowing, partial airway obstruction, or reduced regional tidal inflation can produce this pattern if perfusion persists. The region does not have to be completely unventilated.

A high ratio means that ventilation is large relative to perfusion. Blood supplies comparatively little carbon dioxide and removes comparatively little oxygen from the alveolar gas. Alveolar gas approaches the inspired gas composition as perfusion becomes very small.

High ratios can result from reduced regional perfusion, increased ventilation, or both. Pulmonary vascular obstruction, capillary compression, and loss of vascular bed are possible mechanisms. Ventilation reaching such regions contributes less efficiently to clearing the carbon dioxide carried by the total blood flow.

The words low and high describe a continuum. They do not identify a disease by themselves, and the clinical significance depends on the amount of flow involved. A very abnormal ratio in a tiny region can contribute less to the arterial mixture than a moderately low ratio receiving substantial perfusion.

Wagner and colleagues measured distributions in advanced COPD and found different patterns: predominantly high ratios, predominantly low ratios, or both. Similar arterial gases could accompany dissimilar distributions. Their study demonstrates why a diagnostic label or arterial gas alone cannot reconstruct the regional exchange pattern. 5

31.5 Shunt and Dead Space Are Limiting Cases

In the conventional steady-state compartment model, shunt is perfusion without effective ventilation. The ratio is zero because its ventilation numerator is zero while blood flow continues. Blood passing through a completely unventilated region does not acquire oxygen from fresh alveolar gas and contributes venous blood to the arterial mixture.

The opposite limiting case is ventilation without perfusion. The denominator approaches zero, so the ratio approaches infinity. Such alveolar ventilation cannot exchange gas with blood because no blood reaches it. This is alveolar dead space in the idealized model.

Finite low-ratio units are distinct from true shunt. They still receive some ventilation, which allows inspired oxygen changes to influence their gas composition. Finite high-ratio units are distinct from completely unperfused units. Some exchange still occurs, although ventilation is inefficient relative to blood flow.

Physiological dead space also includes conducting-airway gas that does not reach exchanging surfaces. It is therefore broader than the alveolar limiting case. Practical carbon-dioxide-based estimates can reflect multiple sources of inefficiency; their numerical value does not map directly onto one anatomical unperfused volume.

Dantzker and colleagues used inert gas measurements in patients with ARDS and identified blood flow through shunt or very low-ratio compartments alongside better exchanging regions. Their study supports the coexistence of very different regional conditions within one lung. It does not require every injured lung to have the same distribution or treatment response. 6

The model assumes effective gas supply is represented by the ventilation term. Special conditions such as passive oxygen inflow into an open airway during minimal tidal ventilation require additional analysis. Zero observed tidal movement is not, in every possible setting, proof of zero oxygen supply.

The next chapter examines shunt and physiological dead-space measurements in more detail. Here, their role is to define the extremes of the matching problem without replacing the continuum between them.

31.6 Blood Streams Mix According to Oxygen Content

Regional blood streams bring quantities of oxygen into the pulmonary veins. Their mixture must conserve that oxygen. The appropriate quantity to combine is oxygen content, expressed as oxygen volume per blood volume, rather than the oxygen partial pressure of each stream.

Partial pressure describes the dissolved-gas tension that drives diffusion. Content includes oxygen carried by hemoglobin and oxygen dissolved in blood. Their relationship is nonlinear because hemoglobin saturation changes nonlinearly with oxygen tension. The relationship also depends on hemoglobin concentration, temperature, pH, and other factors.

Consider two illustrative blood streams with the same hemoglobin concentration. One carries 20 mL O₂/dL and supplies 80% of the total flow. The other carries 15 mL O₂/dL and supplies 20%. The first content describes oxygen in each deciliter of well-oxygenated blood. The second describes oxygen in each deciliter of the less oxygenated stream.

Calculate each contribution before adding them: 0.80 × 20 = 16 mL O₂/dL, and 0.20 × 15 = 3 mL O₂/dL. The mixed content is 16 + 3 = 19 mL O₂/dL. The weights sum to one, so the result represents oxygen per deciliter of the combined blood.

This calculation does not give an arterial oxygen tension of 19 mm Hg. It also does not justify taking an average of the two stream oxygen tensions. The final tension must be related to the mixed content using the blood's oxygen-binding conditions.

High-ratio regions cannot usually restore all content lost in low-ratio regions merely by reaching a much higher oxygen tension. Once hemoglobin is nearly saturated, further increases add relatively little bound oxygen. At very high inspired oxygen, dissolved oxygen can add more content, but it still does not make partial-pressure averaging valid.

31.7 Oxygen and Carbon Dioxide Reveal Different Aspects of Mismatch

Ventilation–perfusion inequality impairs the efficiency of both oxygen uptake and carbon dioxide elimination. Its effect on the arterial gases also depends on compensatory ventilation, metabolism, venous blood composition, and the different content–pressure relationships of the two gases.

For oxygen, poorly oxygenated blood from low-ratio regions mixes with blood whose hemoglobin may already be nearly saturated. Additional ventilation to the latter regions may raise their oxygen tension without adding enough content to correct the mixture. Arterial hypoxemia can therefore persist despite substantial total ventilation.

For carbon dioxide, increasing ventilation in adequately perfused, accessible regions can increase elimination and help maintain arterial carbon dioxide tension. This compensation is often more effective than the corresponding compensation for oxygen. A patient can consequently have marked hypoxemia with a normal or low PaCO₂.

That pattern does not mean mismatch leaves carbon dioxide exchange intact. Compensation requires additional ventilation and muscle or ventilator work. If much ventilation reaches high-ratio regions, if mechanical constraints limit ventilation elsewhere, or if carbon dioxide production increases, PaCO₂ can rise despite a large minute ventilation.

West analyzed carbon dioxide retention using lung models and showed how uneven matching can impair elimination even when alveolar gas movement is substantial. His work challenges the assumption that hypercapnia in lung disease always results simply from too little total air movement. 7

The carbon dioxide dissociation relationship and oxygenation-dependent changes in blood carbon dioxide carriage also influence exchange. These mechanisms are developed in Chapter 35. Carbon dioxide's high diffusibility does not remove the need for adequate ventilation to perfused regions.

Interpret PaCO₂ with carbon dioxide production, minute ventilation, dead-space estimates, and respiratory mechanics. A normal value may represent effective compensation at considerable cost, while a rising value may indicate a change in matching, production, ventilatory capacity, or several factors together.

31.8 The Response to Inspired Oxygen Is Informative but Not Unique

Increasing inspired oxygen increases oxygen delivery to regions that receive fresh gas. In many low-ratio units, this raises alveolar oxygen tension and improves oxygenation of the blood leaving them. The ratio itself need not change: more oxygen can enter with the same ventilation and blood flow.

Blood traversing a true shunt does not directly encounter the higher inspired oxygen. Oxygen content can rise in the ventilated blood with which it mixes, but this compensation is limited by hemoglobin saturation and the amount of dissolved oxygen added. Large shunts therefore tend to produce a smaller response than many forms of low-ratio inequality.

The distinction is useful as a mechanism, not as a stand-alone diagnostic test. Very low-ratio units may respond slowly or poorly. Mixed venous oxygen and hemodynamics can change simultaneously. Diffusion limitation and low inspired oxygen also respond to supplemental oxygen, so improvement does not uniquely establish one cause of hypoxemia.

Inspired oxygen can also change the lung being assessed. It may alter hypoxic vascular responses and the amount of nitrogen remaining within poorly ventilated regions. If fresh gas cannot adequately replace absorbed gas, lung volume and airway patency can change.

Dantzker, Wagner, and West analyzed the instability of poorly ventilated units during oxygen breathing in a classical compartment model. Their work helped explain how changing inspired gas could alter measured shunt rather than merely reveal a fixed abnormality. 8

Later modeling by Butler and colleagues emphasized passive oxygen inflow and mechanical support from neighboring lung. Low tidal ventilation alone did not imply inevitable collapse when an airway remained patent. This qualification matters: airway closure and gas absorption can produce atelectasis, but a low ratio is not a universal collapse threshold. 9

31.9 Incoming Venous Oxygen and Cardiac Output Modify the Arterial Result

The lung receives blood after the tissues have extracted oxygen. Mixed venous oxygen content therefore reflects arterial delivery, tissue oxygen use, blood flow, and the distribution of extraction. It is an input to pulmonary gas exchange, not simply a consequence of lung function.

When all blood becomes fully oxygenated in well-matched lung units, changes in incoming venous content may have relatively little effect on the final content. In shunt and low-ratio regions, blood retains more influence from its incoming state. A fall in mixed venous oxygen can then worsen arterial oxygenation without any new loss of ventilation.

Use an illustrative two-stream model with 80% fully oxygenated flow at 20 mL O₂/dL and 20% shunted flow at a venous content of 15 mL O₂/dL. The arterial content is 0.80 × 20 + 0.20 × 15 = 19 mL O₂/dL. If venous content falls to 10 while the assumed flow fractions and oxygenated content stay fixed, the result becomes 16 + 2 = 18 mL O₂/dL.

Dantzker and Bower studied patients with chronic pulmonary vascular disease and found that low mixed venous oxygen contributed importantly to hypoxemia alongside ventilation–perfusion inequality. Their small physiological study illustrates how substantial hypoxemia need not imply an equally large new distribution defect. 10

Cardiac output can influence several parts of this process. At a given oxygen consumption, lower flow often requires more extraction and lowers venous oxygen content. Changing flow can also redistribute perfusion, alter vascular recruitment, and change the fraction passing through shunt regions. These effects can oppose one another.

Dantzker, Lynch, and Weg observed reductions in both cardiac output and shunt during ventilatory interventions in ARDS. The study showed that an apparent gas-exchange improvement can partly reflect a circulatory change. It does not justify reducing cardiac output to improve oxygenation. 11

Systemic oxygen delivery depends on blood flow as well as arterial content. A better PaO₂ or shunt measurement can accompany worse tissue delivery if flow falls sufficiently. Follow circulation and extraction alongside arterial gases.

31.10 Hypoxic Vasoconstriction Can Improve Local Matching

Low alveolar oxygen can increase resistance in nearby pulmonary vessels. If other lung regions remain better oxygenated, the resistance difference can divert some blood toward them. Less blood then traverses the poorly ventilated region, increasing its ventilation relative to perfusion and reducing its contribution to poorly oxygenated outflow.

This is a regional matching response. Its benefit depends on the availability of better exchanging regions and on the ability of their vessels to accept additional flow. It cannot create ventilation in a closed airway or restore a destroyed exchange surface.

When hypoxia is widespread, many vascular regions constrict together. There is less opportunity to redirect flow toward normal lung, and pulmonary vascular pressure and right ventricular load may rise. A locally helpful response can therefore have a different consequence when most of the lung is involved.

Marshall and colleagues altered the size and oxygen tension of hypoxic lung segments in dogs. They observed both diversion of flow from hypoxic regions and changes in perfusion pressure, with responses depending on how much lung was hypoxic. Their experiment demonstrates why local redistribution and whole-lung vascular effects must be distinguished. 12

Vascular obstruction, inflammation, vasoactive drugs, and the incoming venous oxygen state can modify the response. One should not assume that it perfectly compensates for an airway or alveolar abnormality. Nor does a plausible matching mechanism establish that globally increasing or reducing pulmonary tone will improve a patient's outcome.

Chapter 36 develops the vascular signaling and circulatory consequences in more detail. For gas exchange here, the key point is that perfusion can respond to local gas conditions, so ventilation and blood flow are interacting variables rather than independent fixed inputs.

31.11 MIGET Measures a Distribution Rather Than an Anatomical Map

The multiple inert gas elimination technique, abbreviated MIGET, uses gases with different blood solubilities to investigate ventilation–perfusion distributions. Under appropriate steady conditions, their elimination depends differently on the relationship between alveolar ventilation and blood flow.

After administration of dissolved inert gases, investigators measure their concentrations in blood and expired gas, alongside the physiological flows required by the method. A mathematical model then estimates how ventilation and perfusion are distributed across a range of ratios. The different gases provide overlapping information about that distribution.

Wagner, Saltzman, and West developed the theoretical framework for estimating continuous distributions from multiple inert gas measurements. This work made it possible to study inequality more fully than a single ideal-compartment description. The resulting estimate remains an inference constrained by the measurements and model. 13

The distribution is functional rather than a direct image of specific anatomical segments. A low-ratio component does not identify which lobe contains it. Spatial imaging and inert gas analysis therefore answer related but different questions.

Finite resolution also matters. Data do not identify an unlimited number of independently measured alveolar compartments. Distinguishing extremely low ratios from operational shunt categories depends on the method's sensitivity and assumptions. Rapidly changing ventilation, blood flow, or gas stores can violate the steady conditions needed for straightforward interpretation.

At the bedside, arterial gases, capnography, oxygen response, imaging, and hemodynamic assessment provide partial clues. None is a substitute for a measured complete distribution. The appropriate inference is often that several mechanisms are plausible, with one or more strengthened by the trajectory and supporting measurements.

31.12 Integrate the Distribution With Gas Supply and Circulation

Consider an illustrative ventilated patient with new hypoxemia, patchy lung opacities, a normal PaCO₂, and an increased oxygen requirement. These findings are compatible with blood flowing through low-ratio or shunt regions. The normal carbon dioxide does not exclude major inequality; additional ventilation may be maintaining carbon dioxide elimination.

Next examine the inputs. Verify inspired oxygen delivery and the ventilation measurement. Assess airway obstruction, changes in regional aeration, ventilator interaction, and the timing of the deterioration. A change in gas delivery or total alveolar ventilation can coexist with regional mismatch.

Then review perfusion and incoming venous oxygen. A fall in cardiac output or an increase in tissue oxygen use can reduce venous oxygen content. If blood continues through poorly exchanging regions, this can lower arterial content even when lung imaging and ventilator settings appear unchanged. New pulmonary vascular obstruction or vascular compression can create additional high-ratio regions and redirect blood elsewhere.

An oxygen increase that improves PaO₂ supports an oxygen-responsive component. It does not determine whether the lung has only low-ratio inequality, exclude coexisting shunt, or prove recruitment. Likewise, an improvement after a pressure change can result from altered aeration, redistributed perfusion, changed cardiac output, or a combination.

Follow the joint trajectory of oxygenation, carbon dioxide elimination, mechanics, circulation, and tissue perfusion. If PaO₂ improves while cardiac output and systemic delivery deteriorate, the arterial gas alone overstates benefit. If PaCO₂ remains normal only with a large increase in ventilation, gas-exchange efficiency may still be worsening.

This framework avoids forcing one arterial measurement to describe the entire lung. It connects regional ventilation, regional blood flow, blood oxygen content, and venous return to the final arterial mixture. The following chapters examine shunt, dead space, diffusion, and oxygen transport as complementary parts of that system.

References

1. Wagner PD, Laravuso RB, Uhl RR, West JB. Continuous distributions of ventilation-perfusion ratios in normal subjects breathing air and 100 per cent O₂. J Clin Invest. 1974;54(1):54–68. doi:10.1172/JCI107750

2. West JB, Dollery CT. Distribution of blood flow and ventilation-perfusion ratio in the lung, measured with radioactive carbon dioxide. J Appl Physiol. 1960;15(3):405–410. doi:10.1152/jappl.1960.15.3.405

3. West JB, Dollery CT, Naimark A. Distribution of blood flow in isolated lung; relation to vascular and alveolar pressures. J Appl Physiol. 1964;19(4):713–724. doi:10.1152/jappl.1964.19.4.713

4. Petersson J, Rohdin M, Sánchez-Crespo A, et al. Regional lung blood flow and ventilation in upright humans studied with quantitative SPECT. Respir Physiol Neurobiol. 2009;166(1):54–60. doi:10.1016/j.resp.2009.01.008

5. Wagner PD, Dantzker DR, Dueck R, Clausen JL, West JB. Ventilation-perfusion inequality in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease. J Clin Invest. 1977;59(2):203–216. doi:10.1172/JCI108630

6. Dantzker DR, Brook CJ, Dehart P, Lynch JP, Weg JG. Ventilation-perfusion distributions in the adult respiratory distress syndrome. Am Rev Respir Dis. 1979;120(5):1039–1052. doi:10.1164/arrd.1979.120.5.1039

7. West JB. Causes of carbon dioxide retention in lung disease. N Engl J Med. 1971;284(22):1232–1236. doi:10.1056/NEJM197106032842202

8. Dantzker DR, Wagner PD, West JB. Instability of lung units with low V̇_A/Q̇ ratios during O₂ breathing. J Appl Physiol. 1975;38(5):886–895. doi:10.1152/jappl.1975.38.5.886

9. Butler JP, Malhotra A, Loring SH. Revisiting atelectasis in lung units with low ventilation/perfusion ratios. J Appl Physiol. 2019;126(3):782–786. doi:10.1152/japplphysiol.00354.2018

10. Dantzker DR, Bower JS. Mechanisms of gas exchange abnormality in patients with chronic obliterative pulmonary vascular disease. J Clin Invest. 1979;64(4):1050–1055. doi:10.1172/JCI109542

11. Dantzker DR, Lynch JP, Weg JG. Depression of cardiac output is a mechanism of shunt reduction in the therapy of acute respiratory failure. Chest. 1980;77(5):636–642. doi:10.1378/chest.77.5.636

12. Marshall BE, Marshall C, Benumof J, Saidman LJ. Hypoxic pulmonary vasoconstriction in dogs: effects of lung segment size and oxygen tension. J Appl Physiol. 1981;51(6):1543–1551. doi:10.1152/jappl.1981.51.6.1543

13. Wagner PD, Saltzman HA, West JB. Measurement of continuous distributions of ventilation-perfusion ratios: theory. J Appl Physiol. 1974;36(5):588–599. doi:10.1152/jappl.1974.36.5.588